Water Street Bagel Co. Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the Menu at Water Street Bagel Co.
Located in Syracuse, NY, Water Street Bagel Co. is a delightful haven for bagel lovers and brunch enthusiasts alike. The menu boasts a harmonious blend of breakfast and lunch offerings, featuring an array of freshly baked bagels and sandwiches that are sure to please.
- Breakfast Sandwiches: From the classic Bacon, Egg, and Cheese to the innovative Spicy Vegan, each sandwich is crafted with quality ingredients, like fresh eggs and house-made pesto mayo.
- Lunch Options: Signature sandwiches like The New Yorker, filled with thinly sliced pastrami and Swiss, showcase the culinary creativity that defines Water Street.
- Bagels: Choose from a variety of bagels, including the flavorful French Toast and iconic Rosemary Salt, or opt for a "surprise" bag of daily specials.
Don't miss the warm atmosphere, friendly service, and quick order fulfillment that make dining here a pleasure. Whether savoring a breakfast sandwich or indulging in a bagel treat, Water Street Bagel Co. delivers a memorable dining experience!
Bagels
(5) One Day Old Bag
A bag of 5 bagels that were baked the day before, it is a "surprise" bag of bagels, they are prebagged the day before- **Bagels can not be chosen**
(6) One Day Old Bag
A bag of 6 bagels that were baked the day before, it is a "surprise" bag of bagels, they are prebagged the day before- **Bagels can not be chosen**
Plain' (V)
Everything' (V)
Cinnamon Raisin' (V)
French Toast'
English Muffin' (V)
Salt & Pepper' (V)
Onion' (V)
Spicy Everything' (V)
Rosemary Salt' (V)
Sesame Seed' (V)
Poppy Seed' (V)
Asiago Cheese''
Little Northern Bakehouse Gluten Free Plain Bagel'
The ONE EGG Bacon Classic
Double smoked bacon, 1 egg, American Cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The ONE EGG Classic-Sausage
Sausage, 1 egg, American Cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The ONE EGG Classic-Ham
Ham, 1 egg, American Cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Egg & Cheese (2 Eggs)
2 eggs, American Cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Egg White & Cheese
Egg whites and American cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Nice 'N Spicy
Double Smoked Bacon, fresh egg, in-house pickled jalapenos, Sriracha sauce and pepper jack cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Nova Salmon
Acme Smoked Nova Salmon from Brooklyn, NY, fresh ripe tomato, red onion, capers, plain cream cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Basic "Lox"
Acme Smoked Nova Salmon from Brooklyn, NY, and plain cream cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Maple
Sausage, 1 egg, 100% pure maple syrup drizzle from 'Dutch Hill Maple' and Cheddar Cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Western
Double smoked bacon, egg, red & green peppers, red onions, cheddar cheese and house made chipotle sauce on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Spicy Vegan
Vegan Beyond Meat Sausage Patty, vegan Tofutti Cream Cheese, avocado, red peppers, red onions, & Franks Red Hot Sauce **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Vegan Patty With Egg
Beyond Meat Vegan Patty and one egg **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Jersey
Taylor Ham, Egg, American Cheese, Salt, Pepper, Ketchup
Breakfast Sandwiches
Lunch Sandwiches
The New Yorker
Thinly sliced pastrami, egg, swiss cheese, & Guldens spicy brown mustard on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Turkey Bacon Ranch
Thinly sliced oven roasted turkey, crispy double smoked bacon, roasted red peppers, bibb lettuce, Cheddar cheese, & ranch dressing on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Cranberry
Thinly sliced oven roasted turkey, house made cranberry spread, sliced Granny Smith apples, bibb lettuce, cheddar cheese, & honey mustard on**Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Caprese Turkey
Thinly sliced oven roasted turkey, fresh mozzarella, spinach, fresh ripe tomato, house made pesto mayo, & balsamic drizzle on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Super Veggie
Fresh cucumbers, spinach, tomato, red onion, sprouts, & roasted garlic humus on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
BLT
Double smoked bacon, bibb lettuce, tomato, & mayo on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Vermonter
Maple aioli, Granny Smith Apples, cheddar cheese, double smoked bacon, & Turkey on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Full Pepperoni Pizza Bagel
Seasoned pizza sauce, shredded mozzarella, cup & char pepperoni slices on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Full Cheese Pizza Bagel
Seasoned pizza sauce, shredded mozzarella on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
VEGAN CHEESE Full Pizza Bagel
Our seasoned pizza sauce, & shredded Daiya Vegan Mozzarella Cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Jalapeño Popper
Our house made Jalapeno Cream Cheese, cheddar cheese, double smoked bacon, & house made pickled jalapenos on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Monte Cristo
Thinly sliced ham, 1 egg, Swiss cheese, & Pure Maple Syrup drizzle from "Dutch Hill Maple" on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The ADK
Thinly sliced ham, bacon, egg, cheddar, & house made honey walnut cream cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Albuquerque
Turkey, avocado, chipotle mayo, bibb lettuce, red onion, & pepper jack cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Buffy
Scallion Cream Cheese, red onions, sprouts, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, & cucumbers, on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The United
One egg, Bacon, avocado, and Cheddar Cheese **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
The Hot Honey Egg
Bacon, Egg, Cheddar, Scallion Cream Cheese, & Mikes Hot Honey
Ham And Swiss
Thinly sliced Ham off the bone, Spicy Gulden Mustard, Dill pickle chips, & swiss cheese on **Choice Bagel** PLEASE NOTE: If your preferred bagel choice becomes unavailable, we will sub plain or the closest thing.
Daily Specials
Grab & Go's
Extra Large Chocolate Chip Cookie
Baked fresh daily!
8 Oz Plain Cream Cheese
8 Oz Specialty Cream Cheese
Dirty Potato Chips
Cold Brew Coffee By Salt City Coffee
Hot Coffee By SkyTop *USDA Organic Medium Roast By Peru M.P
Organic* Hot Tea By Equal Exchange
Tropicana (12oz)
Soda
Gatorade
Gatorlyte By Gatorade
Pure Leaf Iced Tea (18.5 Oz)
Ripely Farms Milk (16oz)
Naked Juice (15.2oz)
Kombucha * Blueberry Social
BUBBLY Sparkling Water
Propel (20oz)
Bottled Water
Celsius
Beverages
T-Shirts
Silver T-Shirt
Silver/Grey unisex Bella-Canvas T-shirt